Research note 001

Why we separate “recommended” from “suggested”

A law firm can appear in an AI answer without being recommended. FirmRanker records how each firm is treated, not just whether its name appears.

The problem

Many simple AI visibility tools count a firm as visible if its name appears anywhere in a response. That collapses very different outcomes into one number. A firm explicitly recommended for the user's situation is in a different position from a firm included in a neutral list, a firm named in passing, or a firm mentioned in a cautionary context.

If those outcomes are counted the same way, a mention rate is reported as if it were a recommendation rate — and visibility is overstated.

Why it matters

A law firm can appear in an AI answer without being recommended.

For a law firm, the commercially meaningful question is rarely “were we named?”. It is “were we put forward to the person asking?”. A prospective client reading an answer responds differently to “I would recommend starting with Firm A” than to “firms operating in this area include Firm A, Firm B and Firm C”.

Example

Prompt
Which personal injury firms in Toronto would you recommend?
Response A
Several firms operating in Toronto include Firm A, Firm B and Firm C.
Response B
I would recommend starting with Firm A and Firm B.

Both responses answer the same recommendation-seeking prompt. In Response A the firms are listed; the system does not express a preference. In Response B the system explicitly directs the user towards two firms. FirmRanker would classify the firms in Response A as suggested, and Firm A and Firm B in Response B as recommended.

How FirmRanker handles it

Classification is applied per firm, per observation, and can be reviewed by a human against the preserved raw answer.

  • Mentioned — Appears substantively but is not placed into an actionable consideration set.
  • Suggested — Presented as a firm the user may consider.
  • Recommended — Explicitly recommended or endorsed by the system.
  • Source-only — Appears in source material but is not substantively surfaced.
  • Negative / cautionary — Appears in a materially adverse or cautionary context.

What we still don't know

The boundary between a strong suggestion and a recommendation is not always clear-cut, and phrasing differs between AI systems. We are measuring how often automated classification agrees with human reviewers before relying on these categories for published findings. We do not yet know how much readers' choices differ between suggested and recommended firms.

FirmRanker is an international research and intelligence platform studying how AI systems discover, surface, cite and recommend law firms.

One ecosystem. Three ways to help your firm.

Measure with FirmRanker. Understand with Law By Dan. Act with Practice Proof.

FirmRanker: Measure

Find out whether AI includes your firm in your local market, wherever you are based. Start with a free check, then explore the research behind the answers.

Check your firm free

Law By Dan: Understand

Make sense of the shift in legal discovery. Read Dan Toombs’ analysis and follow The Future Client briefing.

Read Dan’s analysis

Practice Proof: Act

Put the findings to work. Get help with your firm’s positioning, reputation, content, search and technology.

Talk to Practice Proof

Follow The Future Client, Dan Toombs’ free weekly briefing for law-firm leaders.

Get The Future Client

Implementation services are separate from research. Being a Practice Proof client does not influence FirmRanker findings.